In honor of the MMM reboot, I thought it was time to design a new header. Thanks to my graphic designer extraordinaire Topher Rhys for the new Maven 2.0 banner. I think its pretty bitchin’ (yes, I know Inception + Scott Pilgrim are on there before they’re released — I don’t care. They’re going to be frickin awesome).
Also, I thought it was time to share my Emmy picks for the year. Now unlike most blogs you’ll read on the subject, these are my ACTUAL Emmy picks. For the 4th year in a row, I voted for the Primetime Emmy Awards. Each category is voted on by the corresponding peer group (i.e. actors vote for acting categories), so I was only able to vote in the Program categories. You’re allowed to nominate up to 10 shows in each category. Sometimes I voted for all 10, sometimes less, whoever I thought truly deserved the title of “Best.” Without further ado, some of my picks and some notes on why I voted how I did:
Best Variety, Music, Comedy Program
1) Tosh.0 2) The Soup 3) Tim & Eric Awesome Show Great Job
Notable Non-vote: Saturday Night Live
Couldn’t vote for SNL this year. It was far from the best, and as much as I love the show and its performers, I didn’t want to take votes away from the more deserving shows listed above. Joel McHale is as sharp as ever on The Soup, Tosh.0 is a bigger and better The Soup for the internet, and Tim & Eric is the most specific and unique comedy on television, period. Also, its only 15 minutes long, which is awesome when you’re in a jam for time but want to laugh for a little. Of all these, my favorite is probably Tosh.0 — if you haven’t watched it yet, do check it out. I GUARANTEE you will laugh. Often.
Best Drama
1) Dexter 2) Breaking Bad 3) Friday Night Lights 4) Lost 5) Rescue Me 6) Mad Men 7) Spartacus: Blood & Sand 8) 24
Notable Non-vote: Big Love
Man, these are some great f’ing tv shows. I voted for FNL and Breaking Bad even though I haven’t watched the former in 2 years or the latter ever, b/c I know they’re good. Breaking Bad is beloved by many people whose opinions I trust and FNL was so great when I watched it and, according to these same people, is still kicking ass. The other 6 shows fall into three tiers. On the lower tier are Dexter, Mad Men and 24. I LOVE these shows and have seen every single season of each. All 3 delivered excellent seasons last year (Mad Men’s was probably strongest in comparison to its previous seasons), are wonderfully cast/written/directed from top to bottom, and have me anxious and excited for their upcoming seasons/movie.
On the next level are Lost and Spartacus. Lost has been a consistently top 3 show in my book for all of its 6 years. Was season 6 the best one? No (Gotta give it to Season 2). Was it still an incredible season and an incredible end to one of the best shows in tv history? You bet. Spartacus is the only new drama I added to my slate this year, and, as a Roman on the show might say, it was fucking incredible. Intense drama, an engaging and visceral visual style, tons of awesome sex and violence, plus the terrific writing/directing/casting you expect from the highest caliber program. Yes, this show is on Starz network (I watched the whole thing through Netflix Instant Watch, which adds new Starz shows minutes after they air. More on Starz later…), but it is a tremendous, tremendous program. Sadly, Andy Whitfield, aka Spartacus, was diagnosed with non-Hodgkins lymphoma during pre-production on Season 2. Fortunately, he is responding well to treatment and will be appearing in a handful of Season 2 episodes. Season 2 will be a prequel, focusing on all of the characters we came to love in Season 1 before Spartacus arrived at the House of Batiatus, and Season 3 will pick up where Season 1 left off. Well played, Starz. Well played.
And alone on top is Rescue Me, which turned in its finest seasons ever in its 5th year (new episodes start in 2 weeks! I can’t friggin wait). Literally each episode was better than the next and the season finale was absolutely mind blowing. Each installment left me gasping for breath, shocked by the drama, guffawing at the jokes, shaking my head at the sheer genius of the writing, which was simply on a higher level than any other show on television. I’ve always loved Rescue Me, but this season took it above and beyond my wildest dreams and expectations. And seeing as how this coming season is the last ever, I have nothing but the highest of hopes for this summer.
Best TV Movie
The Wronged Man
I certainly never watched this TV movie, nor do I have any clue what its about. But it starred none other than Mahershalalhashbaz Ali, everyone’s favorite member of The 4400 and leading contender for “Most Amazing Name in the History of People Having Names.”
Best Comedy
1) Chuck 2) Community 3) Curb Your Enthusiasm 4) It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia 5) The League 6) Party Down 7) Modern Family
Notable Non-Votes: 30 Rock, Parks and Recreation, The Office
I’m sorry NBC, but I didn’t feel that any of your returning shows deserved my vote as the “best” comedy on television. 30 Rock is running out of goodwill in my mind. It’s definitely funny and always has funny writing, but where is it going? The first episode that gave us any semblance of interesting plot this year was the season finale. And the story lines aren’t unified or funny enough to get by being episodic, a la Friends, Seinfeld or It’s Always Sunny. The Office, meanwhile, had a down year. I don’t think anyone would dispute this. Not enough craziness, not enough Kelly/Stanley/Meredith, too much fey Andy. Parks & Rec has an oddly unbalanced cast. I can’t think of another show where half the cast has yet to make me laugh a single time (I’m looking at you Rashida Jones, Aubrey Plaza, Jerry, Donna and Mark). But this show is definitely on the up and up, and I look forward to next (mid)season’s action, with Rob Lowe and Party Downer Adam Scott joining the cast.
I do, however, believe that NBC’s only new comedy, Community, is more than worthy of a Best Comedy nod. There’s no other show like it on television — a diverse cast (featuring 2 smoking hot women — only The League can claim to have this, and both those women aren’t leading players), an incredible balance of real emotional heart and totally surreal situational comedy, awesome/not-at-all-annoying cultural references (from Brat Pack movies to M.A.S.H. to The Warriors to Sesame Street), and a PERFECT balance of serialized/episodic plots. I can’t praise this show enough — its first season was pretty much flawless in my book.
Curb had an undeniable awesome season. Not only did we get the best Seinfeld reunion we could’ve hoped for, but we got instantly classics like peeing on the Jesus painting and the all-time best episode of television dealing with handicapped people. Chuck continued its solid run as one of the best shows that nobody watches (its also the only hour-long comedy I’ve ever seen. Not an easy feat at all.) I’ve talked about Party Down on this blog a few times, and while Season 1 (the season up for the Emmy) was awesome, this season was significantly better, if not brilliant. It’s Always Sunny bounced back after an uneven season 4 to deliver a season full of instant classics, such as “The Gang Renews The Rivalry” or “The D.E.N.N.I.S. System.” Then you’ve got The League, FX’s long-awaited companion comedy for It’s Always Sunny. There were only 6 episodes, but each was better than the next — the show is fresh, appeals strongly to men while ably entertaining women as well, and most importantly, is flat out funny.
Last but not least, you’ve got Modern Family. Originally, I had decided not to vote for the show. There were too many cliches, too much broad humor, too many unfunny female characters and its a show that, in my mind at least, diminishes in quality the more I think about it. But after more thinking, I couldn’t deny the fact that I laughed out loud every episode. Eh. Even now as I write this, I’m waffling again. I think Phil is hysterical. I think Manny and Luke guarantee a laugh or two each every time out. Mitchell and Cam, when they aren’t being inanely broad, are good for some laughs. Then I get to the women. I can’t stand the two daughters; I think they’re just awful. I don’t think having a loud Colombian accent makes Gloria a funny character. And I find Claire to be one note and predictable. I dunno, I just can’t make my mind up on this one. You’ll have one episode that’s thematically strong (take the “Fears” episode, for instance, where each character’s greatest fears is explored), features some hilarious Phil/Luke combos, some hilarious Manny moments, and some solid support work from the others. Then you’ll get an episode without any thematic foundation whatsoever, where the comedic setpiece is Cameron chasing a bird around his house. Really? A fat gay man chasing a bird around his house is the smartest comedy we can come up with? It’s just so uneven for me. It deserves an Emmy nod, because when its good its really good, but I’d love to see some more consistency from Modern Family next season. I know they purposefully keep things broad sometimes to appeal to a wider audience (which they’ve done very successfully and given ABC its first real hit comedy in ages), but I hope in the future that they focus more on writing for their smartest audience, rather than their easiest.